This Is Not My America: What the Pink Coat Witness Revealed

Every once in a while, a single witness forces a nation to confront what it would rather ignore. The woman in the pink coat didn’t go looking for that responsibility. She wasn’t trying to become a symbol or a headline. She was simply a bystander who saw a man in distress, saw federal officers closing in, and understood  in that instinctive, human way  that something was wrong. So she did the one thing ordinary Americans still have the power to do: she pressed record.

Her video didn’t just capture a tragedy. It revealed a truth. It showed Alex Pretti already on the ground when the shots were fired. It showed officers moving his body afterward, turning him over, cutting away clothing, and handling him in ways that shocked the witness. She later described seeing agents appear to count bullet wounds. She also said some agents looked toward the crowd and laughed.

Whether that laughter was nervous, detached, or something else entirely, the effect was the same: it did not look like respect. It did not look like urgency. It did not look like the weight of a human life lost. And that moment  that sound  is why this story matters. Because it forces us to ask what kind of country we are becoming, and whether we’re willing to accept it.

 

This Is Not My America

This is not my America.
And if you care about this country  truly care  then at some point you have to stand up and say no more. No more killing of Americans in the street. No more families blindsided by violence they never asked for. No more ordinary people dying for doing the right thing.

Alex Pretti was trying to help someone who had been pepper‑sprayed. That’s it. A simple act of human decency  the kind we claim to value. And somehow, that moment of compassion ended with a man lying on the pavement, surrounded by federal officers, while a woman in a pink coat recorded because she knew something was terribly wrong.

Her video shows what it shows: Alex already on the ground when the shots were fired. And then, after he had passed, the camera keeps rolling. You can see officers moving his body. You can see them turning him over. You can see actions that the witness interpreted as counting bullet wounds. And you can hear reactions from agents that she described as laughter.

Whatever the reason for that behavior, it didn’t look like accountability. And it certainly didn’t look like the America we’re told to believe in.

Because Americans real Americans  do not treat human life that way.
Real Americans do not laugh over a body.
Real Americans do not shrug off the death of a man who tried to help someone in distress.
Real Americans do not hide behind shifting statements and half‑truths.

They are not Americans. They are not part of my America.

My America is built on compassion, not cruelty. On accountability, not excuses. On the belief that helping someone in pain is an act of courage, not a fatal mistake. My America is a place where bystanders are witnesses, not threats. Where truth matters. Where power is restrained by responsibility.

If you care about your country if you care about the future we’re leaving to our children then you cannot look away. You cannot accept a version of America where stepping in to help another human being becomes a death sentence. You cannot accept a system where federal officers can take a life and then behave as if nothing sacred has been lost.

This is not my America.
And it shouldn’t be yours either.
If we want a country worth believing in, we have to stand up and say it clearly, loudly, and without apology:
No more.   

Author’s Note

I am not anti‑ICE. I am anti‑abuse of the American people.
Supporting law enforcement does not mean accepting every action without question. It does not mean ignoring harm, dismissing misconduct, or staying silent when something is clearly wrong. Real patriotism includes demanding accountability, transparency, and respect for human life especially from those who carry authority in our name.

Author Disclaimer:

This article reflects my analysis as a writer who relies on publicly available information, eyewitness statements, and verified reporting. I am not affiliated with any political group, media outlet, or legal commentator. My goal is to present information clearly, responsibly, and with appropriate context.

Some details discussed here come directly from eyewitness testimony, including statements made by Stella Carlson (the woman in the pink coat) during her CNN interview and in her sworn affidavit. These statements are reported as her account. When a detail is unverified by additional witnesses or not visible on available footage, I identify it as such.

Commentators like Nate the Lawyer focus strictly on what can be confirmed through video evidence. My reporting includes both the documented footage and the firsthand accounts of individuals who were physically present, with clear distinctions between the two. Readers should consider all sources as part of an evolving picture, and ongoing investigations may provide additional clarity over time.

Written by Susang6 — blogger gardener, animal lover, and creator.

View her studio and Blogger profile here.