Why We Sound Mean Online (Even When We’re Not)
If you’ve ever typed something completely harmless only to have someone
respond as if you’d personally insulted their ancestors you’ve experienced the
strange phenomenon of why we sound mean online even when we’re not.
Digital communication strips away tone, facial expression, and all the subtle
cues that help people understand our intentions. Without those signals, even
friendly comments can read as abrupt, sarcastic, or downright hostile.
And the wild part?
Most of the time, the “mean” tone people hear isn’t actually there. Their brain
fills in the blanks… and it doesn’t always fill them kindly.
The Tone Problem: Why We Sound Mean
Online (Even When We’re Not)
When we read text, our brains automatically assign tone and they’re
notoriously bad at it. Without body language, timing, or a smile to soften the
edges, even neutral statements can come across sharper than intended.
Researchers have found that online communication is uniquely vulnerable to
misinterpretation because we’re working with fewer emotional cues than in face‑to‑face
conversation.
In other words:
Your “LOL” might sound like “I’m laughing AT you,”
and your “Sure.” might read like “I hate everything you stand for.”
This is the heart of why we sound mean online even when we’re not the
medium itself invites misunderstanding.
My Own Case Study: Becoming the
Accidental Online Villain
I’m naturally off‑the‑cuff. I speak quickly, honestly, and sometimes
without the benefit of a mental editor. In person, that comes across as funny,
blunt, or charmingly unfiltered. Online? Apparently, it reads as sarcasm,
snark, and the occasional “Is she… mean?” moment.
Over the years, I somehow earned a reputation as that commenter the
one who must be having a bad day, every day.
Spoiler: that’s not who I am.
But the internet doesn’t see my smile, my tone, or the fact that I’m probably
petting a cat while typing.
This is another example of why we sound mean online even when we’re
not people assume tone based on
their mood, not ours.
The Arch Enemy Who Wasn’t
For seven years, I had an online “arch enemy.” We clashed constantly not
over anything important, just the usual internet Olympics of “who knows more?”
He’d tell me to “go to my corner,” which pushed every button I had, and I’d
fire back with equal intensity.
Were our debates enlightening?
Absolutely.
Did they reflect who we were as actual humans?
Not even close.
When we finally met in person, I discovered he was quiet, reserved, and
surprisingly witty. He spoke only when spoken to and listened more than he
talked. And he discovered I was kind, caring, and shockingly not the fire‑breathing
dragon my comment history suggested.
We’ve been friends ever since.
And that friendship is living proof of why we sound mean online even
when we’re not because the real people behind the screens are often
nothing like the tone we imagine.
So Why Do People Seem More Assertive
(or Aggressive) Online?
Research shows that assertiveness is often misread as aggression especially
in environments lacking nonverbal cues. Several factors contribute to this:
1. No Nonverbal Cues = Maximum
Misinterpretation
Without tone, facial expression, or body language, even neutral
statements can feel confrontational.
2. The Online Disinhibition Effect
People feel freer to express strong opinions online because they’re not
face‑to‑face. This can make them appear more assertive or more abrasive than they really are.
3. Cultural and Social Biases
Assertive communication is often judged more harshly depending on gender,
culture, or social expectations.
4. Unclear Social Hierarchies
In online spaces, people may over‑assert themselves to compensate or be perceived that way even when they’re not
trying.
5. Our Brains Default to Caution
When tone is ambiguous, humans tend to assume the worst. It’s a survival
instinct… just not a helpful one in the comments section.
The Takeaway: We’re Softer Than Our
Typing Makes Us Look
Most people aren’t as harsh, sarcastic, or confrontational as they appear
online. They’re just communicating through a medium that strips away warmth,
nuance, and humanity.
And sometimes, your “arch enemy” is actually a quiet, witty person who
becomes a lifelong friend once you meet them in real life.
Footnote / Disclaimer
This story is based on the real nine‑year online‑to‑offline
journey of Brian Harmony and Susan Golis. Yes they truly did argue online for seven straight years before finally meeting in 2024. And yes the moment they met, all the imagined “meanness” melted away. Since then, they’ve taken road trips together, talk daily, support each other
through life’s highs and lows, and have become
genuine friends.
Brian has become the “big brother” type steady, kind, a good
listener, and someone who can make Susan laugh even in her darkest hour. And
Susan? Well, during Brian’s last visit, he told her she was “kind, caring, and
a loving person.” It only took him two years to figure that out… but better late
than never.
This article is meant to enlighten, not accuse. It’s a
reminder that online tone is fragile, easily misread, and often nothing like
the real person behind the screen. A single sarcastic comment without an emoji
can brand someone as “mean,” and that label can stick far longer than it
should.
So before you post, pause. Add clarity. Add kindness. Add an
emoji if you’re being witty. And remember: the person on the other side of the
screen might just be someone you’d end up road‑tripping with someday.
Comments